Triple downgrade for Argentina's flood-hit soybean crop


Argentina's flood-threatened soybean hopes received a triple downgrade, with the country's farm ministry and two grains exchanges cutting sowing estimates – but not as deeply as some other commentators have done.

The Buenos Aires grains exchange - which two weeks ago cut its forecast for Argentina's soybean sowings for 2016-17 by 300,000 hectares, blaming drought in southern areas - downgraded the total by a further 100,000 hectares, citing "new rains received last weekend" in inundated areas further north.

The downgrade, left the plantings estimate at 19.2m hectares, a drop of 900,000 hectares year on year.

Separately, Argentina's farm ministry issued a bigger downgrade to its sowings forecast, of 500,000 hectares, although this still left officials with a 19.8m-hectare estimate, bigger than that of the exchange.

"In south eastern Buenos Aires, in the centre of Santa Fe and parts of Cуrdoba, a significant number of fields were left unsown," said the ministry, whose data show an 800,000-hectare drop in soybean area year on year.

And the Rosario grains exchange, which has gone as far as making production estimates, cut its forecast for output by 1.5m tonnes to 52.9m tonnes.

The figure was based on ideas that flooding has cost 710,000 hectares of soybeans in the of north Buenos Aires province and south of Santa Fe provinces, with further 300,000 hectares in southern Buenos Aires lost to drought

Soy rally

The revisions follow enhanced concern, and speculation, over the extent of losses to Argentina's soybean crop from rains which, according to a report in La Nacion, have landed rains of up to 60mm – equivalent to nearly 2 feet - on the country over the past month.

Worries were provoked in particular over inundations last weekend, fuelling a rally in Chicago soybean futures of 6% over four sessions, driving the spot March contract to a six-month high on Wednesday.

The prospect of soy crop losses has also spurred a surge in Chicago soymeal futures, which soared 11.5% in the four sessions to Wednesday, with Argentina the top exporter of the high protein feed ingredient.

Varying estimates

But the grains exchange and ministry estimates remain more conservative of those from some other commentators on estimates for losses to the heavy rains, which La Nacion said seriously affected nearly 2.5m hectares of land overall, while potentially a further 1m hectares less severely inundated.

At US broker CHS Hedging, Joe Lardy said that the exchange "numbers are in sharp contrast to many private analysts that think over 2m hectares have been lost and total production is down to around 50m-51m tonnes", from the 57m tonnes at which the US Department of Agriculture has pegged the crop.

Earlier this week, Michael Cordonnier, the influential soybean and corn analyst, said that "the amount of soybean hectares impacted might be in the range of 2,000,000 hectares and counting, or approximately 10% or more" of total area.

"The lost hectares are some of the most productive in Argentina and once the area dries out, it will be too late to do any replanting.

"Therefore, the hectares that are currently flooded will probably be a complete loss."

The Buenos Aires grains exchange said that "to date it is estimated that some 770,000 hectares of soybeans are affected by excess water.

"Depending on the weather during the next weeks, the amount of crop lost would exceed half of this area."

Corn prospects

The exchange also said that 290,000 hectares of corn sowings, mainly in Buenos Aires, Cordoba, Entre Rios and Santa Fe provinces, were "at risk" from the heavy rains, but kept is estimate for Argentina sowings of the grain at 4.90m hectares.

More than 95% of this area has been seeded – compared with a progress rate of some 68% a year ago.

The farm ministry, meanwhile, kept its estimate for Argentina corn plantings, including crop intended for silage, at 7.25m hectares, but flagged "severe flooding" in Buenos Aires, Cordoba and Santa Fe "that will have a negative impact on final production".


Readers choice: TOP-5 articles of the month by UkrAgroConsult